A.S., D.I., O.I. and G.D. v. Italy

Comment:

Joint opinion of Committee members Yuval Shany, Christof Heyns and Photini Pazartzis (dissenting); individual opinion of Committee member Andreas Zimmermann (dissenting); individual opinion of Committee member David H. Moore (dissenting); individual opinion of Committee member Gentian Zyberi (concurring); individual opinion of Committee member José Manuel Santos Pais (concurring); individual opinion of Committee member Vasilka Sancin (concurring); individual opinion of Committee member Hélène Tigroudja (concurring)

Substantive issues:

• cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
• effective remedy
• right to life

Substantive articles:

• 2 (3)
• 6
• 7

Procedural issues:

• exhaustion of domestic remedies
• jurisdiction

Procedural articles:

• 1
• 5 (2) (b)